Todd Russell

4/25/2024

Reflective Assessment Phil 355

In this class, I learnt about consequentialism, deontology, and the Equifax breach. My understanding and viewpoint have shifted, providing greater insights and guiding principles for ethical decision-making.

Consequentialism, at its foundation, assesses the morality of an action based on the consequences. Initially, I liked its simplicity. However, as I dug deeper, I discovered the intricacies it overlooks. Intentions and fundamental values are important, just like outcomes. My viewpoint has developed to include both consequentialist and deontological features. I’ve come to see that, while consequences are important, they must be examined within the context of moral principles and rights. Takeaway: Strive for a balanced ethical approach that takes into account both outcomes and principles.

In contrast, deontology promotes adherence to moral principles or responsibilities regardless of the consequences. I initially grappled with its rigidity, worrying it would lead to moral absolutism. However, as I continued to interact, I realized the importance of establishing clear moral principles in the face of uncertainty. My perspective has developed to see the value of moral principles while also understanding the need for flexibility in their implementation. This balanced viewpoint acknowledges the significance of duties while accounting for contextual factors. Takeaway: Maintain moral duties while remaining open to contextual modifications that are consistent with broad ethical ideals.

The Equifax leak put my comprehension of these ethical theories to the test. Initially, I concentrated primarily on the consequences—the financial and human ramifications for millions of people. However, when I reflected further, I recognized that the breach also violated the concepts of autonomy, privacy, and corporate responsibility. My worldview grew as I battled with firms’ ethical responsibility in protecting sensitive information. In dealing with such intricate difficulties, I realized how consequentialist and deontological arguments are intertwined. Takeaway: Making ethical decisions necessitates a comprehensive strategy that takes into account the complex consequences of actions on individuals and society.

Finally, my involvement with consequentialism, deontology, and the Equifax breach has resulted in a more sophisticated understanding of ethical theories and their application in real-world situations. I’ve learned to manage the tensions between outcomes and ideals, and I understand the significance of striking a balance between the two in making ethical decisions. As I move forward, I hope to remember the interconnection of these theories and the importance of considering other points of view in ethical discussions. My takeaway is to embrace complexity, be open to new ideas, and strive for ethical actions that balance consequences and principles.