We recently generated some of the first long high resolution (annual to near-annual) paleohurricane reconstructions of the past two millennia from blue holes on: South Andros, Middle Caicos, and Long Island. All three records captured century-scale periods of elevated hurricane activity, like nothing we’ve seen in the modern, followed by periods of relative quiescence. An important takeaway from comparing these blue hole records is that neighboring islands capture different populations of storms, and thus no single island record can be used to reconstruct regional hurricane climate. Instead, we create regional compilations of published paleohurricane records in the Atlantic. These compilations indicate regional heterogeneity in tropical cyclone strikes with the Bahamas and New England capturing similar patterns of storm activity that contrast with activity reconstructed in the Gulf of Mexico.